645 Commercial Street

To be vibrant and successful, an art colony needs more than artists. It needs an entire human infrastructure, or ecosystem: provisioners, dealers, patrons, collectors, critics, buyers, and camp followers. It also needs at least one champion connoisseur, someone who — though associated with the place — enjoys a high enough national stature as to be a credible and compelling advocate. In the mid-20th century, Hudson Dean “Huddie” Walker (1907-1976) was the champion connoisseur of the Provincetown art colony. He lived here with his wife, Ione Avery (Gaul) Walker (1914-1987). The name “Walker” probably rings several bells. If you’re familiar with the contemporary art scene in town, you certainly know the Berta Walker Gallery at 208 Bradford Street. She is one of his daughters. And if you’re familiar with the contemporary art scene nationally, you’ll wonder whether he’s related in any way to the Walker Art Center in Minneapolis. He is.

Hudson Walker was the grandson of Thomas Barlow Walker (1840-1928), a Western lumberman. Thomas Walker collected art and donated to Minneapolis some 8,000 pieces valued at $5 million, nearly $70 million in today’s currency; then built a museum to house it when the city equivocated. “Even as a child I was interested in collecting things,” the younger Walker reminisced in 1957. “When I was 11, I had a playhouse and I filled it with my collections. They included guns, swords, colored stones, porcelain, stuffed birds and sea shells.” Soon, his passion extended to the works — among others — of Alfred Henry Maurer (1868-1932) and Marsden Hartley (1877-1943), who had a Provincetown connection through his friend John Reed, at 592 Commercial Street.

The younger Walker was educated at the University of Minnesota and also at the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard. In the 1930s, in succession, he was a partner in the Goodman-Walker Art Gallery in Boston, the first curator at what would become the Weisman Art Museum at the University of Minnesota and the director of the Hudson Walker Gallery at 38 East 57 Street in New York. (He would later run the jewelry company Walker, Ebeling-W. E. Marcus at 18 East 48th Street.)

Ione Avery Gaul, meanwhile, had been spending summers in Provincetown since childhood. She had studied at Carnegie Tech and with the artist Arthur Silz (1901-1956) in Provincetown. Her father, Harvey Bartlett Gaul, was a composer, organist and music critic in Pittsburgh. Her mother, Harriet Avery, was a writer. And Ione’s brother, James, had attended Harvard, where he’d met and befriended one Hudson Walker, to whom Ione was introduced. They married in 1936. Their three daughters were Berta; her twin, Louise (Walker) Davy; and Harriet (Walker) “Hatty” Fitts.

The Walkers vacationed in Provincetown in 1943 and liked it so much that they purchased 645 Commercial Street in 1945. This one of the five gambrel-roofed homes in the neighborhood that were built by Horace Albertus Spear Jr. (1864-1934); the others being Nos. 642, 646, 647 and 648.

The year in which the Walkers bought No. 645 was also when he became president of the American Federation of Arts. Though they lived most of the year in Forest Hills Gardens, Queens, Walker found the time to keep exceptionally busy on the Cape. In 1958, for instance, he served as one of the founding incorporators of the Chrysler Art Museum, which occupied what is now the Public Library, at 356 Commercial. In 1961, he was elected president of the Provincetown Art Association, 460 Commercial.

But by far the work for which he is best remembered in town is the establishment of the Fine Arts Work Center, of which he was one of the most steadfast patrons — so much so that its gallery is named in his honor. He saw the need for such a place years before it was organized. Quite presciently in 1962, Walker told The Advocate:

I believe that Provincetown is the most significant summer art colony in the country. … A real threat to the continuance of this situation is the great need for low-cost living quarters and studios for the younger artists. The local art schools are excellent, but it will be difficult for them to continue to attract students without adequate housing, and other younger artists will have to seek inexpensive living conditions elsewhere.

“Hudson and Ione wrere among the founders, chief bankroller and pole around whom all gathered,” Roger Skillings told me in 2012, “second in time only to the Del Deos, who provided the effective impetus, dating from a letter of February 6, 1964 to Josephine from Pat Saffron Van Derek, Napi’s mother, on the state of Provincetown’s decline into raw commerce and real estate.”


[Updated 2012-08-08]




2 thoughts on “645 Commercial Street

  1. Great article, just found by my sister Louise. There is one area I think should be made clearer. Harvey and Harriet Gaul started coming to Provincetown with their children, Ione and James, in 1915 (came by train that ended on the wharf!). Thus the trip in 1943 (which you refer to as the first vacation here) was actually a continuance of the Gaul family’s treks to the Provincetown Eat End(except during WWI). In 1944, my mother had decided she wanted a place of her own in the East End, put out feelers and got 645 from the elderly couple who was selling and wanted a young family to buy the house (obviously, there’s a lot more to this tale).
    As a side note: my grandparents were a part of the Provincetown Players when it started. Also, my grandfather was an early, if not founding member, of the Beachcombers Men’s Club, a club for artists’ and writers and those associated with the arts in town.

  2. This is a fascinating piece, David. What will happen to this article or has it been published?
    In actuality, our grandparents came to Town in 1915 and it’s a ratter fun story.

    Thus. 2015 is not only the Centennial of The Privincetown Theater, but it is also the Centennial of Modernist Blanche Lazzell’s arrival, and finally,
    the summer of 1915 saw the artival from Pittsburgh of Harvey Bartlett Gaul and Harriette Avery, who most came every year thereafter. So David, come back to Provincetown and let me take you to dinner in celebration of your incredible contributions to Provincetown history
    and the Gaul/Walkers’ arrival in Provincetown! Or we can go back to the Pilgrims with whom we ALSO arrived! Always affection and admiration,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s